I think 2 things have been established, proven, verified, etc. without a doubt:
1. Artificials catch perch
2. live bait catches perch
When it comes to fishing, a very wise man( my dad) once told me
...To each his own......
Whatever method you employ to catch those tasty perch, as long as you are enjoying yourself while you are doing it, that is what counts.
I give kudos to CLP, as he has obviously mastered the technique of using artificials to catch perch. You could not just walk up to the shore, throw an artificial bait in the water, and expect to catch perch. You need to know what presentations to use, what baits to use, what depths, where the fish are, etc. He has shown that he knows what he is doing
...and the same goes to Big Saw with live bait. You can not just show up anywhere on the shore with live bait and catch perch. You need to know the same things....what presentations to use, what depths the fish are at, where the fish are, what they are biting on, etc. there have been many times I have been out fishing for perch with an assortment of live bait, and myself and my father will be using the same setups, and he will be catching nothing on minnows and I am killing them on nightcrawlers. Big saw has proven he knows how to catch perch also
Guys, we all enjoy fishing. I enjoy seeing different ideas, presentations, etc on how to catch fish, as I believe most people do.
GOD BLESS EVERYONE WHO CATCHES PERCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Now that being said, we need to get a fish-off between CLP and Big Saw. Let those 2 decide the time, location, day, etc. I bet it would be safe to say that each guy would get his limit.......But really, I could care less how many fish either guy got, I just want to see the 2 standing next to each other